Data updated

Update Information

Buffalo's Best Roofing Company

Membership: Not a member

Not yet claimed

Public Records Check

  • Locally Regulated New York doesn't issue a statewide roofing license - roofing is regulated locally through city or county permits, so there is no state license to verify. We don't count this against Buffalo's Best Roofing Company. Confirm any local permit or registration with the city or county where the work will take place.
  • Registered Corporation Buffalo's Best Roofing Company's registered name carries a corporate suffix (LLC or Inc), but we have not matched it to a filing on the New York Secretary of State. You can confirm how the business is registered, and its current status, directly with the New York Secretary of State.
  • Unverified Address Buffalo's Best Roofing Company's listed address at 4589 Genesee Street, Rochester, NY 14225 appears to be a unconfirmed address. A roofer using a mailbox isn't necessarily a problem, but it can make the company harder to reach or hold accountable. To reach them in person, ask the contractor for a physical address or confirm one directly.
  • 2 Credentials Buffalo's Best Roofing Company holds these manufacturer certifications: CertainTeed ShingleMaster Premier, Owens Corning Preferred. These show the company met a manufacturer's program requirements and may offer manufacturer-backed warranties, but they aren't independent quality audits. You can confirm current status with the manufacturer.
  • Excellent Ratings Across the platforms we identified for Buffalo's Best Roofing Company (Google, Yelp, the Better Business Bureau, CertainTeed), the blended average is 4.6 out of 5, which we label Excellent. This is a plain average of public customer ratings, not a RooferWatch score. A high average reflects past customers' experiences, not a guarantee of yours, so read the underlying reviews and weigh them yourself.

We verified 4/5 public records for Buffalo's Best Roofing Company. The more of a company's record you can check, the more informed your hiring decision.

Contact Info

About this alternate phone

CertainTeed reports this number as the primary phone number for this business. It may be an old number that the owner forgot to update, or a secondary number.

About this alternate address

CertainTeed reports this location as the primary address for this business. It may be an old location that the owner forgot to update, or a secondary address.

Company Description

Buffalo's Best Roofing Company serves residential and commercial customers throughout Western New York, including Monroe, Erie, Genesee, Niagara, Wyoming, Ontario, and Chautauqua counties. The company offers residential roofing services including roof inspection, repair, replacement, and installation in asphalt shingles and metal roofing materials. Commercial roofing services include inspection, repair, replacement, installation, and roof coatings using TPO, EPDM, and modified bitumen materials. Additional exterior services include gutter installation, siding, windows, doors, concrete, and deck work. Emergency services include roof storm damage repair, roof tarping, and ice dam removal. The company reports over 100 combined years of experience and more than 6,000 completed jobs. It holds a CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster certification and maintains a BBB A+ rating.

Services Offered

Credentials

  • CertainTeed CertainTeed ShingleMaster Premier

    CertainTeed ShingleMaster Premier

    CertainTeed ShingleMaster Premier is CertainTeed's highest contractor credential and the top tier of their Contractor's EDGE program, which replaced the previous SELECT ShingleMaster designation in 2026. It is held by… Read more

  • Owens Corning Owens Corning Preferred

    Owens Corning Preferred

    An Owens Corning Preferred contractor has earned the mid-tier designation in Owens Corning's contractor network by demonstrating installation quality, business stability, and customer satisfaction. This status… Read more

Company Info

Company Name
Buffalo's Best Roofing Co., LLC
Entity Type
Limited Liability Company (LLC)
Address Type
Unverified
Multi-State Company
No
Website Age
8.4 years old

Inspections and Violations

U.S. Department of Labor data
Inspections 9
Violations 12
Current penalties $11,518
Most recent Jun 2026
  1. Jun 12, 2026 LANCASTER, NY Insp #348996307
  2. Aug 26, 2025 CHEEKTOWAGA, NY Insp #348491630
  3. Aug 2, 2023 BUFFALO, NY Insp #346891872
    • Serious Fall protection required on scaffolds over 10 ft 1926.451(g)(1)(i) $2,300
    • Other Hard hats required where head injury possible 1926.100(a) $0
  4. Jul 25, 2023 BUFFALO, NY Insp #346866189
  5. May 25, 2023 BUFFALO, NY Insp #346742554
  6. Aug 18, 2022 BUFFALO, NY Insp #346154651
    • Serious Steep roofs - fall protection required 1926.501(b)(11) $2,818
    • Other Ladder extends 3 ft above landing 1926.1053(b)(1) $0
  7. Aug 9, 2019 BUFFALO, NY Insp #344239017
    • Other PFAS rigged so free fall cannot exceed 6 ft 1926.502(d)(16)(iii) $0
    • Serious Steep roofs - fall protection required 1926.501(b)(11) $1,500
  8. Jul 8, 2019 BUFFALO, NY Insp #344142419
    • Serious Ladder extends 3 ft above landing 1926.1053(b)(1) $0
    • Repeat Fall protection required on scaffolds over 10 ft 1926.451(g)(1)(i) $1,500
    • Repeat Steep roofs - fall protection required 1926.501(b)(11) $0
    • Other Scaffold platform construction 1926.451(b)(5)(ii) $0
  9. Jun 21, 2018 BUFFALO, NY Insp #343257127
    • Serious Fall protection required on scaffolds over 10 ft 1926.451(g)(1)(i) $1,700
    • Serious Steep roofs - fall protection required 1926.501(b)(11) $1,700

Reviews and Reputation

About this review summary

This summary was automatically generated from customer reviews that were publicly visible at the time it was created on one or more of the review aggregators listed below. It does not constitute a review, rating, endorsement, or statement of fact about the business - it reflects only the opinions expressed by those reviewers as found at that time, not the views or conclusions of RooferWatch. Automated summaries can contain errors or omit context and may become outdated as new reviews are posted, so please read the original reviews through the links provided and do your own due diligence. If you are the business owner and believe anything here is inaccurate, submit a correction and we’ll review it promptly.
  • Avg. Rating 4.6
  • BBB A+
  • Google 4.9
  • Yelp 3.9
  • CertainTeed 4.4

Reviewers report mixed experiences with Buffalo's Best Roofing. Several customers describe positive interactions, praising the company's pricing, professionalism, and work quality. Many reviewers highlight responsive communication, efficient job completion, thorough cleanup, and courteous crew members. Some customers report satisfaction with warranty offerings and the company's responsiveness to post-installation issues. However, one reviewer expresses significant dissatisfaction, describing careless work practices, inadequate protective measures during a multi-day project, damage to their property and neighbors' properties, delayed completion beyond promised timelines, and an absent owner who failed to visit the job site. This reviewer characterizes the crew as unprofessional and reckless. Another reviewer reports the company as non-responsive and demanding full upfront payment without a confirmed work date.

About this average rating

This figure is a straightforward average of the public ratings we’ve gathered for this company across the following review platforms that our systems have identified: Google, Yelp, the Better Business Bureau, CertainTeed. It is not a proprietary RooferWatch score or a judgement of our own; each source is converted to a common five-star scale and blended into a single number so that no one platform’s reviews carry outsized weight, giving a more balanced read on overall sentiment. We’d still encourage you to read the underlying reviews on each platform and weigh them for yourself.

Review Signals Over Time

About these review signals

These figures are derived from this company’s 30 most recent publicly visible Google reviews at the time they were gathered. They simply describe patterns in those reviews - how often new reviews appear, how often the owner replies, and whether recent star ratings run higher or lower than older ones. They are not a review, rating, endorsement, or judgement by RooferWatch, and they reflect only what those public reviews showed at that time, which can change as new reviews are posted. Please read the underlying reviews and do your own due diligence. If you are the business owner and believe anything here is inaccurate, submit a correction and we’ll review it promptly.
~34.5/mo Reviews per month
87% Owner responds to reviews
Declining 4.8 recent vs 4.9 earlier
How customers rated Buffalo's Best Roofing Company each month
Number of new reviews Buffalo's Best Roofing Company received per month

By sheer volume of Google reviews (a measure of how much feedback a firm has gathered) Buffalo's Best Roofing Company ranks 2nd of the 18 roofers we track in Rochester, ahead of about 94% of them. Over the past year it has pulled in 30 reviews - the most recent this month - for a rate of roughly 34.5 reviews per month, which is faster than approximately 100% of the other Rochester roofers. Its 4.9-star average rating sits right at the Rochester median of 4.9 stars. The owner responds to 87% of reviews, which is above the typical Rochester roofer’s rate of 16%.

Service Areas

Leave a Review for Buffalo's Best Roofing Company

About these customer reviews

Reviews below are submitted by members of the public and reflect only the opinions of those individuals, not the views, conclusions, or endorsement of RooferWatch. We screen submissions before publishing but cannot independently verify each reviewer’s experience. If you are the business owner and believe a review is inaccurate, please log in and report the review in question.

Write a review

Your rating
See all in Rochester