Public Records Check
- Registration-Based Wisconsin doesn't license roofing contractors; instead it requires a statewide contractor registration. We treat this check as met rather than penalise it, but we haven't independently verified this company's registration - confirm it directly with the state before hiring.
- Registered Corporation Nickols Roofing's registered name carries a corporate suffix (LLC or Inc), but we have not matched it to a filing on the Wisconsin Secretary of State. You can confirm how the business is registered, and its current status, directly with the Wisconsin Secretary of State.
- Business Address Nickols Roofing's listed address at 415 West Wisconsin Avenue, Appleton, WI 54911 appears to be a business address. This means the company operates from a real, locatable address rather than a mailbox or PO box, which can make it easier to reach them or resolve issues. Many roofers legitimately work from a home address, so this doesn't speak to the quality of their work, license, or insurance.
- 1 Credential Nickols Roofing holds these manufacturer certifications: Owens Corning Preferred. These show the company met a manufacturer's program requirements and may offer manufacturer-backed warranties, but they aren't independent quality audits. You can confirm current status with the manufacturer.
- Excellent Ratings Across the platforms we identified for Nickols Roofing (Google, the Better Business Bureau), the blended average is 5.0 out of 5, which we label Excellent. This is a plain average of public customer ratings, not a RooferWatch score. A high average reflects past customers' experiences, not a guarantee of yours, so read the underlying reviews and weigh them yourself.
We verified 5/5 public records for Nickols Roofing. The more of a company's record you can check, the more informed your hiring decision.
Contact Info
-
Phone
This phone number belongs to an iPhone, not a landline, so both calling and texting is supported.(920) 841-1069
-
Primary Address
415 West Wisconsin Avenue, Appleton, WI 54911
-
Alternate Address
1373 Kimberly Dr, Neenah, WI 54956
-
Owner Email
-
Website
nickolsroofing.com
- Socials
Company Description
Nickols Roofing has 25 years of experience serving residential customers across Northeast Wisconsin, including Green Bay, Appleton, Neenah, Oshkosh, and Fond Du Lac. The company offers residential roof replacement and repair, gutter installation and repair, and attic insulation services. Nickols Roofing reports having completed over 1,500 trades and installed more than 100,000 linear feet of gutters. The company states it is fully licensed and insured and operates a quality assurance process called the Buffalo Stamp of Approval, which documents and verifies each project from quote through final inspection. Services are provided to Fox Valley homeowners and their families across Northeast Wisconsin.
Services Offered
- Residential Roof ReplacementRemoving and replacing an entire residential roof system with new materials.
- Residential Roof RepairFixing leaks, damaged shingles, flashing, and other issues on residential roofs.
- Gutter InstallationSetting up gutters and downspouts to channel water away from the roof and foundation, preventing water damage and erosion.
- Gutter RepairFixing leaks, reattaching loose sections, replacing damaged gutters, or realigning gutters to ensure proper water drainage away from the foundation.
- Attic InsulationInstallation of fiberglass, cellulose, or foam insulation in attic spaces to reduce heat loss, lower energy costs, and improve comfort.
Credentials
-
Owens Corning Preferred
An Owens Corning Preferred contractor has earned the mid-tier designation in Owens Corning's contractor network by demonstrating installation quality, business stability, and customer satisfaction. This status… Read more
Company Info
- Lead-Safe (RRP)
- N/A
- License Number
- 032300342
- License Type
- False
- Company Name
- Nickols Roofing LLC
- Entity Type
- Limited Liability Company (LLC)
- Contractor ID
- 95099472
- Address Type
- Commercial
- Multi-State Company
- No
- Website Age
- 4.3 years old
Sample of Permits Pulled
| Date | Project | Location | Value | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roofing Reroofing the house and attached garage. . a maximum of two layers of shingles are allowed to be installed on any roof. this permit does no… Permit #202508063 | 364 Windingbrook Dr, Oshkosh, WI, 54904 | $12,873 | issued | |
| Siding Replacing the siding on the 3 gable ends of the house. about 6 sq of siding Permit #202507203 | 2130 Vinland St, Oshkosh, WI, 54901 | $4,673 | issued | |
| Roofing Reroofing the house only. a maximum of two layers of shingles are allowed to be installed on any roof. this permit does not include any str… Permit #202506770 | 717 Franklin St, Oshkosh, WI, 54901 | $13,041 | issued | |
| Exterior combination Removing 12 skylights patching over and installing new shingles on the first section. replacing 10 existing skylights with new skylights th… Permit #202506435 | 1825 W Pointe Dr, Oshkosh, WI, 54902 | $15,968 | issued | |
| Roofing Reroofing the house and detached garage. a maximum of two layers of shingles are allowed to be installed on any roof. this permit does not … Permit #202506282 | 2130 Vinland St, Oshkosh, WI, 54901 | $10,378 | issued |
Showing 5 recent permits from public records. This list is incomplete and may be out of date - verify any permit directly with the issuing city or county building department before relying on it. Did you spot any incorrect information here? Please let us know.
Inspections and Violations
U.S. Department of Labor dataReviews and Reputation
-
Avg. Rating
-
BBB A+
-
Google
Reviewers consistently praise Nickols Roofing for professionalism, attention to detail, and quality workmanship. Several customers report that staff members - particularly Willie and Josh - were responsive, knowledgeable, and easy to work with throughout projects. Reviewers describe the installation crews as efficient and respectful, noting that teams completed work quickly, cleaned up thoroughly at day's end, and protected landscaping. Many customers appreciate the detailed explanations of options and transparent communication about project timelines and costs. Reviewers highlight specific strengths including careful inspection of roofs and attics, willingness to make adjustments, and ability to handle both large and small projects. Several customers note competitive or reasonable pricing relative to other quotes received. Reviewers also mention the company's use of quality materials, including Malarkey shingles made with recycled content. Overall, customers express high satisfaction and indicate they would recommend the company.
Review Signals Over Time
By sheer volume of Google reviews (a measure of how much feedback a firm has gathered) Nickols Roofing ranks 3rd of the 12 roofers we track in Appleton, ahead of about 82% of them. Over the past year it has pulled in 30 reviews - the most recent this month - for a rate of roughly 5.2 reviews per month, which is faster than approximately 80% of the other Appleton roofers. Its 5.0-star average rating sits right at the Appleton median of 5.0 stars. The owner responds to 0% of reviews, which is in line with the typical Appleton roofer’s rate of 0%.
